3954 Polly Court

Williamsburg VA 23188


$585,500 | 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | 2-car garage Car Parking | 3055 Square Feet | MLS: 10589018




Welcome to 3954 Polly Court

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home, thoughtfully updated for comfort and convenience. Three spacious bedrooms are located on the main level, while the fully finished basement features a large fourth bedroom, an additional living area, and a full bathroom—easily accessible with a chair lift. The basement also offers ample unfinished storage space.  The kitchen is designed for ease with pull-out cabinets for effortless access to your cookware. Enjoy grilling year-round on the outdoor deck with a bump-out. Gutter guards have been installed to keep maintenance low. The basement benefits from a split HVAC system, and utility access is a breeze with the HVAC and water heater located in a dedicated room off the extended garage.  Power outages are no concern here—with a generator, you’ll always stay connected.  And, for more peace of mind the HVAC, Irrigation System, Generator, Water System, Termite/moisture, and chair-lift either have a maintenance contract or is checked yearly.


Please upload a video first on the edit property page, under advanced settings.

Welcome to 3954 Polly Court


Welcome to this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home, thoughtfully updated for comfort and convenience. Three spacious bedrooms are located on the main level, while the fully finished basement features a large fourth bedroom, an additional living area, and a full bathroom—easily accessible with a chair lift. The basement also offers ample unfinished storage space.  The kitchen is designed for ease with pull-out cabinets for effortless access to your cookware. Enjoy grilling year-round on the outdoor deck with a bump-out. Gutter guards have been installed to keep maintenance low. The basement benefits from a split HVAC system, and utility access is a breeze with the HVAC and water heater located in a dedicated room off the extended garage.  Power outages are no concern here—with a generator, you’ll always stay connected.  And, for more peace of mind the HVAC, Irrigation System, Generator, Water System, Termite/moisture, and chair-lift either have a maintenance contract or is checked yearly.



Features:
  • Generator
  • Irrigation system
  • Extended deck
  • Walk-out basement
  • Gas Fireplace
  • Chair-Lift
  • Tray ceiling
  • Gutter Guards





Available Documents:





There are currently no open houses scheduled for this property. Please contact me for a private showing.



About Judy McCormick

Along with being a Realtor in 2 different states for over 14 years and a Mentor for the past 2-years; Judy has worked in Marketing Research for over 30 years in various supervisory positions, including Integrated Technology and Human Resources.  

She also obtained a Masters degree in Special Education and worked as a teacher.  As well as working in the fitness industry part-time for over 35 years as a manager, trainer and instructor. 

Along with her various work background; Judy’s other interests include, playing tennis, gardening, bicycling, reading and doing word search and jigsaw puzzles. 

She supports the Heritage Humane Society and has two rescue cats, Mercy and Cheez-IT.  Also, she supports the William and Mary Tennis team.    

Judy and her husband have 4 adult children and 6 grandchildren.   She loves living in Williamsburg and would be glad to either sell your home or find you a home in the area.

Proudly represented by:


Judy McCormick

Fathom Realty

Visit My Website
Mobile Phone: 757-727-3255
Williamsburg, VA

Questions?




This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers 3,055 square feet featuring a walk-out finished basement with a chair-lift, gas fireplace, tray ceiling, extended deck, generator, irrigation system, and gutter guards.

Questions about 3954 Polly Court

Listing information updated October 9, 2025

How many bedrooms does 3954 Polly Court have?

3954 Polly Court has 4 bedrooms.

How many bathrooms does 3954 Polly Court have?

3954 Polly Court has 3 bathrooms.

How big is 3954 Polly Court?

3954 Polly Court is approximately 3,055 square feet.

What is the price of 3954 Polly Court?

3954 Polly Court is listed at $585,500.

Is 3954 Polly Court still available?

As of October 9, 2025, 3954 Polly Court is marked sold.

What features does 3954 Polly Court offer?

Notable features of 3954 Polly Court include Generator, Irrigation system, Extended deck, Walk-out basement, Gas Fireplace, Chair-Lift, Tray ceiling, Gutter Guards.

What parking does 3954 Polly Court have?

Parking at 3954 Polly Court: Car Parking.

How do I schedule a showing of 3954 Polly Court?

Contact listing agent Judy McCormick, or use the contact form on this page. The listing's AI assistant can also answer questions and help arrange a showing 24/7.

What should buyers check on a finished basement in Williamsburg, VA?

Permits and egress first — a below-grade bedroom generally needs a code-compliant egress window or door, and unpermitted finish work can have to come out. Then moisture: look for efflorescence and staining low on the walls, find the sump and drainage setup, and ask directly about past water intrusion. Radon testing is inexpensive and belongs on the same list.

Does a finished basement count in the square footage?

Usually not in the headline figure. Appraisers conventionally report below-grade space separately from above-grade living area even when it is fully finished, and value it at a lower rate. That is why two homes with the same total finished space can appraise quite differently.

Going deeper? Read our guide to what counts as finished, legal, and livable below grade.

Buyer guides: Beachfront homes · Condos & HOAs · Single-story living · All buyer guides